Mar
17

The Real Ruby

Filed Under (Uncategorized) by brandilholmes on 17-03-2008



To be perfectly honest, I had never heard of Ruby Payne until Ed.S.  Since she is supposed to be this poverty-educating guru, I was a little suprised that I had never heard of her until now.  After reading the words of Anita Bohn I was a little shocked.  How can someone claim to be so knowledgeable on the area of poverty, yet have no research to back it up?  And then to learn that she publishes her own work so she doesn’t even have to have the research to back it up made it even worse.  I think that so many people buy into what she has to say simply because they are desperate to seek some kind/any kind of help to better their teaching situation.  I don’t think that children in poverty are any less intelligent than any other student.  If we treat them like they are incapable, we are just hindering them from the start.  I was truly appalled at her “hidden rules for lower class and hidden rules for middle class”.  Does every person in a poverty situation really know how to get a hand gun if the have a police record?  It is almost as if she was implying that simply living in poverty one will eventually have a police record.  I truly try hard not to pass judgement on someone unless I’ve done the research myself, but the things that Anita Bohn points out in her article are just too huge to overlook.  You better believe that I will now think twice before attending a Ruby Payne seminar or purchasing a Ruby Payne book.

Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

One Response to “The Real Ruby”

  1.   jdennis5 Says:

    I think many people listen because it provides an explanation to things that teachers onder about. However, I think it is such a success because there is no shared responsibility with government or education… It is viewed as “their problem.” It sure is easy to understand someone else’s problems when you accept no resonsibility in creating part of the problem…It makes the presentations nice and neat to listen to. I went to a presentation. I have the book. I understand it a little bit differently now…

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image